• +1 (303) 506-6362
  • jasmine@jasminekendig.com
jasmine kendig

The Limitations of Zillow Estimates & Instant Home Valuations

image of home valuation graphic.

Let’s talk about those instant home value estimates – like Zillow’s "Zestimate."

They’re quick, they’re easy, and they give you a number in seconds. But are they really accurate enough to use when you’re deciding one of the biggest financial moves of your life?
As a Realtor who’s helped many homeowners in Colorado navigate the selling process, I can tell you: Zillow estimates can be a helpful starting point – but they should never be your final answer.
Here’s why relying solely on instant valuations can be risky, and what you should do instead.

What Zillow Can’t See

They’re quick, they’re easy, and they give you a number in seconds. But are they really accurate enough to use when you’re deciding one of the biggest financial moves of your life?
As a Realtor who’s helped many homeowners in Colorado navigate the selling process, I can tell you: Zillow estimates can be a helpful starting point – but they should never be your final answer.
Here’s why relying solely on instant valuations can be risky, and what you should do instead.

Online estimators like Zillow and Redfin use automated valuation models (AVMs). These are algorithms that pull data from public records, recent home sales, square footage, lot size, and a few other generic inputs.

But here’s what they can’t see:

  • You just remodeled your kitchen with high-end finishes? Zillow doesn’t know.
  • Your home backs to a beautiful open space instead of a busy road? It can’t see that either.
  • Your house is in pristine condition while the comp down the street needs new everything? Not factored in.

These tools are simply not equipped to evaluate the real-world nuances that can drastically affect a home’s value.

Even Zillow itself admits their estimates can be off by as much as 5% or more, and that’s in markets where data is plentiful. In some areas, the margin is much wider.

Real Pricing Requires Real Expertise

They’re quick, they’re easy, and they give you a number in seconds. But are they really accurate enough to use when you’re deciding one of the biggest financial moves of your life?
As a Realtor who’s helped many homeowners in Colorado navigate the selling process, I can tell you: Zillow estimates can be a helpful starting point – but they should never be your final answer.
Here’s why relying solely on instant valuations can be risky, and what you should do instead.

Here’s the truth: Numbers matter. But they aren’t the whole story.

I use data tools too, and I always pull comparable sales. But what makes the difference is my experience, local insight, and ability to see what algorithms can’t:

  • The upgrades you’ve made
  • The condition of your home
  • The location and setting
  • The feel and flow of the space
  • The emotional response it creates in buyers

I also know what buyers in our Colorado market are looking for right now. That means I can position your home to attract the right people, not just throw out a price and hope it sticks.

Let's talk

Want to Know What Your Home is Really Worth?

If you’re even thinking about selling, let’s talk. I offer a no-pressure, expert market analysis that gives you a real look at what buyers would pay today.

It’s personal, specific, and based on what matters most: your home, your goals, and the current market — not just a computer’s best guess.

Let’s make sure you get the value you deserve.

A picture of jasmine kendig, realtor.
newsletter

Stay up-to-date with market news

Each month I'll send you market tips and updates to help you navigate the housing world.

Get a FREE buyer's guide

Sign-up below for my newsletter and you'll receive a free copy of my Buyer's Guide to help you get started on your home buying journey.

Plus, you'll be entered into the Red Rocks ticket drawing.
* indicates required

Get a FREE buyer's guide

Sign-up below for my newsletter and you'll receive a free copy of my Buyer's Guide to help you get started on your home buying journey.
* indicates required
* indicates required